Comparative Evaluation of Microtensile Bond Strength of Three Adhesive Systems
-
Shiva Jafarnia
,
Javad Zeinaddini Meymand
,
Fateme Zandkarimi
,
Sogol Saberi
,
Sima Shahabi
,
Alireza Valanezhad
,
Sirus Safaee
,
Mahdis Nesabi
,
Ikuya Watanabe
Abstract
Objectives: The aim of this study was to assess the microtensile bond strength of three universal adhesives to dentin and enamel.
Materials and Methods: Sixty extracted human third molar teeth were chosen and divided into six groups regarding the adhesive (G-Premio Bond, Clearfil S3 Bond or Single Bond) and tooth surface. All the applied bonding agents were universal adhesives. The teeth were polished and the adhesives were applied; then the teeth were restored with composite resin. The samples were mounted in acrylic resin and sectioned. The specimens were subjected to a universal testing machine and the microtensile bond strength was measured. The failure mode of each specimen was determined under a stereomicroscope. Data were analyzed using two-way ANOVA (α=0.05).
Results: The microtensile bond strength of G-Premio Bond to enamel and dentin was 11.79±8.27 and 17.55±9.47 MPa, respectively which was not significantly different from the values in Single Bond group (15.59±10.66 and 17.19±10.09 MPa to enamel and dentin, respectively; P>0.05). However, the values for Clearfil S3 Bond were 7.11±4.23 and 7.88±8.83 MPa to enamel and dentin, respectively, which were significantly lower than the values for G-Premio Bond (P<0.05). Scanning electron microscopic (SEM) images showed that the adhesive failure was dominant in both enamel and dentin groups and in all adhesive systems.
Conclusion: G-Premio Bond and Single Bond provided higher microtensile bond strength compared with Clearfil S3 Bond. Universal adhesives with their acceptable performance can be applied in self-etch mode on both enamel and dentin.
1. Duddu MK, Muppa R, Panthula P, Srinivas NC. Comparison of shear bond strength and microleakage of three commercially available seventh generation bonding agents in primary anterior teeth: an in vitro study. J Indian Soc Pedod Prev Dent. 2015 Jun;33(2):116–21.
2. Nair M, Paul J, Kumar S, Chakravarthy Y, Krishna V, Shivaprasad. Comparative evaluation of the bonding efficacy of sixth and seventh generation bonding agents: An In-Vitro study. J Conserv Dent. 2014 Jan;17(1):27–30.
3. Chandra PVR, Harikumar V, Ramkiran D, Krishna MJN, Gouda MV. Microleakage of class V resin composites using various self-etching adhesives: an in vitro study. J Contemp Dent Pract. 2013 Jan;14(1):51–5.
4. Leprince JG, Palin WM, Hadis MA, Devaux J, Leloup G. Progress in dimethacrylate-based dental composite technology and curing efficiency. Dent Mater. 2013 Feb;29(2):139–56.
5. Nunes MF, Swift EJ, Perdigao J. Effects of adhesive composition on microtensile bond strength to human dentin. Am J Dent. 2001;14(6):340–3.
6. Frankenberger R, Perdigão J, Rosa BT, Lopes M. “No-bottle” vs “multi-bottle” dentin adhesives--a microtensile bond strength and morphological study. Dent Mater. 2001 Sep;17(5):373–80.
7. Cho KM. Phosphoric acid etching for multimode universal adhesive. Restor Dent Endod. 2016 May;41(2):157–8.
8. Kimochi T, Yoshiyama M, Urayama A, Matsuo T. Adhesion of a new commercial selfetching/ self-priming bonding resin to human caries-infected dentin. Dent Mater J. 1999;18(4):437–43.
9. Zhang Z, Wang X, Zhang L, Liang B, Tang T, Fu B, et al. The contribution of chemical bonding to the short- and long-term enamel bond strengths. Dent Mater. 2013 Jul;29(7): e103-112.
10. Hayakawa T, Kikutake K, Nemoto K. Influence of self-etching primer treatment on the adhesion of resin composite to polished dentin and enamel. Dent Mater. 1998 Mar;14(2):99–105.
11. Eick JD, Robinson SJ, Chappell RP, Cobb CM, Spencer P. The dentinal surface: its influence on dentinal adhesion. Part III. Quintessence Int. 1993 Aug;24(8):571–82.
12. Watanabe I, Nakabayashi N, Pashley DH. Bonding to ground dentin by a phenyl-P selfetching primer. J Dent Res. 1994 Jun;73(6):1212– 20.
13. Wang Y, Spencer P. Physiochemical interactions at the interfaces between self-etch adhesive systems and dentin. J Dent. 2004; 32:567– 79.
14. Van Meerbeek B, De Munck J, Yoshida Y, Inoue S, Vargas M, Vijay P, et al. Buonocore memorial lecture. Adhesion to enamel and dentin: current status and future challenges. Oper Dent. 2003 Jun;28(3):215–35.
15. Kugel G, Ferrari M. The science of bonding: from first to sixth generation. J Am Dent Assoc. 2000 Jun;131 Suppl:20S-25S.
16. Breschi L, Mazzoni A, Ruggeri A, Cadenaro M, Di Lenarda R, De Stefano Dorigo E. Dental adhesion review: aging and stability of the bonded interface. Dent Mater. 2008 Jan;24(1):90–101.
17. Bishara SE, Gordan VV, VonWald L, Olson ME. Effect of an acidic primer on shear bond strength of orthodontic brackets. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 1998 Sep;114(3):243–7.
18. Aguilar-Mendoza JA, Rosales-Leal JI, Rodríguez-Valverde MA, Cabrerizo-Vílchez MA. Effect of acid etching on dentin wettability and roughness: self-etching primers versus phosphoric acid. J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater. 2008 Jan;84(1):277–85.
19. Dorminey JC, Dunn WJ, Taloumis LJ. Shear bond strength of orthodontic brackets bonded with amodified 1-step etchant-and-primer technique. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2003 Oct;124(4):410–3.
20. Hewlett ER. Resin adhesion to enamel and dentin: a review. J Calif Dent Assoc. 2003 Jun;31(6):469–76.
21. Miranda C, Maykot Prates LH, de Souza Vieira R, Marino Calvo MC. Shear bond strength of different adhesive systems to primary dentin and enamel. J Clin Pediatr Dent. 2007 Sep;31(1):35–40.
22. Valizadeh S, Moradi A, Mirazei M, Amiri H, Kharazifard MJ. Microshear bond strength of different adhesive systems to dentin. Front Dent. 2019 Aug;16(4):265–71.
23. Miyazaki M, Iwasaki K, Onose H. Adhesion of single application bonding systems to bovine enamel and dentin. Oper Dent. 2002 Feb;27(1):88–94.
24. Inoue S, Vargas MA, Abe Y, Yoshida Y, Lambrechts P, Vanherle G, et al. Microtensile bond strength of eleven contemporary adhesives to enamel. Am J Dent. 2003 Oct;16(5):329–34.
25. Shimada Y, Senawongse P, Harnirattisai C, Burrow MF, Nakaoki Y, Tagami J. Bond strength of two adhesive systems to primary and permanent enamel. Oper Dent. 2002 Aug;27(4):403–9.
26. Pilecki P, Stone DG, Sherriff M, Watson TF. Microtensile bond strengths to enamel of self-etching and one bottle adhesive systems. J Oral Rehab. 2005 Jul;32(7):531–40.
27. Kelsey WP 3rd, Latta MA, Vargas MA, Carroll LR, Armstrong SR. Microtensile bond strength of total-etch and self-etch adhesives to the enamel walls of Class V cavities. Am J Dent. 2005 Feb;18(1):37–40.
28. Miyazaki M, Sato M, Onose H. Durability of enamel bond strength of simplified bonding systems. J Esthet Restor Dent. 2004 Jan;16(1):74.
29. Yazici, AR, Celik, C, Ozgünaltay, G, Dayangaç, B. Bond strength of different adhesive systems to dental hard tissues. Oper Dent. 2007 Mar;32(2):166-72.
30. Poggio C, Beltrami R, Colombo M, Chiesa M, Scribante A. Influence of dentin pretreatment on bond strength of universal adhesives. Acta Biomater Odontol Scand. 2017 Mar;3(1):30–5.
31. Cevik P, Yildirim AZ, Artvin Z, Özcan M. Microtensile bond strength and failure type analysis of self-etch adhesive systems on superficial and deep dentin after long-term water storage. Braz Dent Sci. 2020;23(4):12p–12p.
32. Fabião A de M, Fronza BM, André CB, Cavalli V, Giannini M. Microtensile dentin bond strength and interface morphology of different selfetching adhesives and universal adhesives applied in self-etching mode. J Adhes Sci Trchnol. 2021 Apr 3;35(7):723-32.
33. Van Meerbeek B, Yoshihara K, Yoshida Y, Mine A, De Munck J, Van Landuyt KL. State of the art of self-etch adhesives. Dent Mater. 2011 Jan;27(1):17–28.
34. Pashley DH, Tay FR, Breschi L, Tjäderhane L, Carvalho RM, Carrilho M, et al. State of the art etch-and-rinse adhesives. Dent Mater. 2011 Jan;27(1):1–16.
35. Yaseen SM, Subba Reddy VV. Comparative evaluation of shear bond strength of two selfetching adhesives (sixth and seventh generation) on dentin of primary and permanent teeth: an in vitro study. J Indian Soc Pedod Prev Dent. 2009 Mar;27(1):33–8.
36. Armstrong SR, Keller JC, Boyer DB. The influence of water storage and C-factor on the dentin-resin composite microtensile bond strength and debond pathway utilizing a filled and unfilled adhesive resin. Dent Mater. 2001 May;17(3):268–76.
37. Gre C, Andrada M, Junior S. Microtensile bond strength of a universal adhesive to deep dentin. Braz Dent Sci. 2016 Jul;19(2):104-10.
2. Nair M, Paul J, Kumar S, Chakravarthy Y, Krishna V, Shivaprasad. Comparative evaluation of the bonding efficacy of sixth and seventh generation bonding agents: An In-Vitro study. J Conserv Dent. 2014 Jan;17(1):27–30.
3. Chandra PVR, Harikumar V, Ramkiran D, Krishna MJN, Gouda MV. Microleakage of class V resin composites using various self-etching adhesives: an in vitro study. J Contemp Dent Pract. 2013 Jan;14(1):51–5.
4. Leprince JG, Palin WM, Hadis MA, Devaux J, Leloup G. Progress in dimethacrylate-based dental composite technology and curing efficiency. Dent Mater. 2013 Feb;29(2):139–56.
5. Nunes MF, Swift EJ, Perdigao J. Effects of adhesive composition on microtensile bond strength to human dentin. Am J Dent. 2001;14(6):340–3.
6. Frankenberger R, Perdigão J, Rosa BT, Lopes M. “No-bottle” vs “multi-bottle” dentin adhesives--a microtensile bond strength and morphological study. Dent Mater. 2001 Sep;17(5):373–80.
7. Cho KM. Phosphoric acid etching for multimode universal adhesive. Restor Dent Endod. 2016 May;41(2):157–8.
8. Kimochi T, Yoshiyama M, Urayama A, Matsuo T. Adhesion of a new commercial selfetching/ self-priming bonding resin to human caries-infected dentin. Dent Mater J. 1999;18(4):437–43.
9. Zhang Z, Wang X, Zhang L, Liang B, Tang T, Fu B, et al. The contribution of chemical bonding to the short- and long-term enamel bond strengths. Dent Mater. 2013 Jul;29(7): e103-112.
10. Hayakawa T, Kikutake K, Nemoto K. Influence of self-etching primer treatment on the adhesion of resin composite to polished dentin and enamel. Dent Mater. 1998 Mar;14(2):99–105.
11. Eick JD, Robinson SJ, Chappell RP, Cobb CM, Spencer P. The dentinal surface: its influence on dentinal adhesion. Part III. Quintessence Int. 1993 Aug;24(8):571–82.
12. Watanabe I, Nakabayashi N, Pashley DH. Bonding to ground dentin by a phenyl-P selfetching primer. J Dent Res. 1994 Jun;73(6):1212– 20.
13. Wang Y, Spencer P. Physiochemical interactions at the interfaces between self-etch adhesive systems and dentin. J Dent. 2004; 32:567– 79.
14. Van Meerbeek B, De Munck J, Yoshida Y, Inoue S, Vargas M, Vijay P, et al. Buonocore memorial lecture. Adhesion to enamel and dentin: current status and future challenges. Oper Dent. 2003 Jun;28(3):215–35.
15. Kugel G, Ferrari M. The science of bonding: from first to sixth generation. J Am Dent Assoc. 2000 Jun;131 Suppl:20S-25S.
16. Breschi L, Mazzoni A, Ruggeri A, Cadenaro M, Di Lenarda R, De Stefano Dorigo E. Dental adhesion review: aging and stability of the bonded interface. Dent Mater. 2008 Jan;24(1):90–101.
17. Bishara SE, Gordan VV, VonWald L, Olson ME. Effect of an acidic primer on shear bond strength of orthodontic brackets. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 1998 Sep;114(3):243–7.
18. Aguilar-Mendoza JA, Rosales-Leal JI, Rodríguez-Valverde MA, Cabrerizo-Vílchez MA. Effect of acid etching on dentin wettability and roughness: self-etching primers versus phosphoric acid. J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater. 2008 Jan;84(1):277–85.
19. Dorminey JC, Dunn WJ, Taloumis LJ. Shear bond strength of orthodontic brackets bonded with amodified 1-step etchant-and-primer technique. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2003 Oct;124(4):410–3.
20. Hewlett ER. Resin adhesion to enamel and dentin: a review. J Calif Dent Assoc. 2003 Jun;31(6):469–76.
21. Miranda C, Maykot Prates LH, de Souza Vieira R, Marino Calvo MC. Shear bond strength of different adhesive systems to primary dentin and enamel. J Clin Pediatr Dent. 2007 Sep;31(1):35–40.
22. Valizadeh S, Moradi A, Mirazei M, Amiri H, Kharazifard MJ. Microshear bond strength of different adhesive systems to dentin. Front Dent. 2019 Aug;16(4):265–71.
23. Miyazaki M, Iwasaki K, Onose H. Adhesion of single application bonding systems to bovine enamel and dentin. Oper Dent. 2002 Feb;27(1):88–94.
24. Inoue S, Vargas MA, Abe Y, Yoshida Y, Lambrechts P, Vanherle G, et al. Microtensile bond strength of eleven contemporary adhesives to enamel. Am J Dent. 2003 Oct;16(5):329–34.
25. Shimada Y, Senawongse P, Harnirattisai C, Burrow MF, Nakaoki Y, Tagami J. Bond strength of two adhesive systems to primary and permanent enamel. Oper Dent. 2002 Aug;27(4):403–9.
26. Pilecki P, Stone DG, Sherriff M, Watson TF. Microtensile bond strengths to enamel of self-etching and one bottle adhesive systems. J Oral Rehab. 2005 Jul;32(7):531–40.
27. Kelsey WP 3rd, Latta MA, Vargas MA, Carroll LR, Armstrong SR. Microtensile bond strength of total-etch and self-etch adhesives to the enamel walls of Class V cavities. Am J Dent. 2005 Feb;18(1):37–40.
28. Miyazaki M, Sato M, Onose H. Durability of enamel bond strength of simplified bonding systems. J Esthet Restor Dent. 2004 Jan;16(1):74.
29. Yazici, AR, Celik, C, Ozgünaltay, G, Dayangaç, B. Bond strength of different adhesive systems to dental hard tissues. Oper Dent. 2007 Mar;32(2):166-72.
30. Poggio C, Beltrami R, Colombo M, Chiesa M, Scribante A. Influence of dentin pretreatment on bond strength of universal adhesives. Acta Biomater Odontol Scand. 2017 Mar;3(1):30–5.
31. Cevik P, Yildirim AZ, Artvin Z, Özcan M. Microtensile bond strength and failure type analysis of self-etch adhesive systems on superficial and deep dentin after long-term water storage. Braz Dent Sci. 2020;23(4):12p–12p.
32. Fabião A de M, Fronza BM, André CB, Cavalli V, Giannini M. Microtensile dentin bond strength and interface morphology of different selfetching adhesives and universal adhesives applied in self-etching mode. J Adhes Sci Trchnol. 2021 Apr 3;35(7):723-32.
33. Van Meerbeek B, Yoshihara K, Yoshida Y, Mine A, De Munck J, Van Landuyt KL. State of the art of self-etch adhesives. Dent Mater. 2011 Jan;27(1):17–28.
34. Pashley DH, Tay FR, Breschi L, Tjäderhane L, Carvalho RM, Carrilho M, et al. State of the art etch-and-rinse adhesives. Dent Mater. 2011 Jan;27(1):1–16.
35. Yaseen SM, Subba Reddy VV. Comparative evaluation of shear bond strength of two selfetching adhesives (sixth and seventh generation) on dentin of primary and permanent teeth: an in vitro study. J Indian Soc Pedod Prev Dent. 2009 Mar;27(1):33–8.
36. Armstrong SR, Keller JC, Boyer DB. The influence of water storage and C-factor on the dentin-resin composite microtensile bond strength and debond pathway utilizing a filled and unfilled adhesive resin. Dent Mater. 2001 May;17(3):268–76.
37. Gre C, Andrada M, Junior S. Microtensile bond strength of a universal adhesive to deep dentin. Braz Dent Sci. 2016 Jul;19(2):104-10.
| Issue | Vol 19 (Continuously Published Article-Based) | |
| Section | Original Article | |
| DOI | https://doi.org/10.18502/fid.v19i8.8725 | |
| Keywords | ||
| Dental Cements; Dental Bonding; Dental Enamel; Dentin; Composite Resins | ||
| Rights and permissions | |
|
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. |
How to Cite
1.
Jafarnia S, Zeinaddini Meymand J, Zandkarimi F, Saberi S, Shahabi S, Valanezhad A, Safaee S, Nesabi M, Watanabe I. Comparative Evaluation of Microtensile Bond Strength of Three Adhesive Systems. Front Dent. 2022;19.
