Composite Resin Bond Strength to Zirconia and Base Metal Alloys Using Two Types of Intraoral Porcelain Repair Systems
Bond Strength to Zirconia and Base Metal Alloys
Abstract
Objectives: This study aimed to evaluate the shear bond strength (SBS) of two repair composites (Crea.lign vs. PermaFlo) to a base metal alloy and zirconia ceramic.
Materials and Methods: Sixty-four discs (12mm diameter, 1mm thickness) were fabricated using Wirobond base metal alloy and zirconia. They were then bonded with their respective composite resins (N=16) in each of the two porcelain chipping repair kit subgroups consisting of PermaFlo and Crea.lign. All specimens were stored in 37°C distilled water for 24 hours. Half of them were subjected to 10,000 thermal cycles (5-55°C, 30s). All specimens were tested for SBS with a universal testing machine. Failure types were analyzed using a digital camera. Analysis of the data was done by two-way ANOVA and Bonferroni post-hoc tests.
Results: SBS was significantly affected by the type of composite resin. PermaFlo had a significantly higher SBS than Crea.lign to base metal alloy (P<0.001) and zirconia ceramic (P<0.001). Thermocycling decreased the SBS of both composites to base metal alloy (P<0.001) and zirconia (P<0.001).
Conclusion: A universal adhesive could provide higher shear bond strength of zirconia and base metal alloy to composite resin than Crea.lign composite and the MKZ primer supplied by its manufacturer.
1. Celik G, Ismatullaev A, Sari T, Usumez A. Comparison of the effectiveness of bonding composite to zirconia as a repair method. Int J Appl Ceram Technol. 2016 Mar;13(2):405-11.
2. Moses A, Ganesan L, Shankar S, Hariharan A. A comparative evaluation of shear bond strength between feldspathic porcelain and lithium di silicate ceramic layered to a zirconia core- An in vitro study. J Clin Exp Dent. 2020 Nov 1;12(11):e1039-e1044.
3. Sari F, Secilmis A, Simsek I, Ozsevik S. Shear bond strength of indirect composite material to monolithic zirconia. J Adv Prosthodont. 2016 Aug;8(4):267-74.
4. dos Santos JG, Fonseca RG, Adabo GL, dos Santos Cruz CA. Shear bond strength of metal-ceramic repair systems. J Prosthet Dent. 2006 Sep;96(3):165-73.
5. Singh A, Ramachandra K, Devarhubli AR. Evaluation and comparison of shear bond strength of porcelain to a beryllium-free alloy of nickel-chromium, nickel and beryllium free alloy of cobalt-chromium, and titanium: An in vitro study. J Indian Prosthodont Soc. 2017 Jul-Sep;17(3):261-266.
6. Yesil ZD, Karaoglanoglu S, Akyil MS, Seven N. Evaluation of the bond strength of different composite resins to porcelain and metal alloy. Int J Adhesion Adhesives. 2007 Apr 1;27(3):258-62.
7. Knight JS, Sneed WD, Wilson MC. Strengths of composite bonded to base metal alloy using dentin bonding systems. J Prosthet Dent. 2000 Aug;84(2):149-53.
8. Elsaka SE. Repair bond strength of resin composite to a novel CAD/CAM hybrid ceramic using different repair systems. Dent Mater J. 2015;34(2):161-7.
9. Choi BK, Han JS, Yang JH, Lee JB, Kim SH. Shear bond strength of veneering porcelain to zirconia and metal cores. J Adv Prosthodont. 2009 Nov;1(3):129-35.
10. Sarafianou A, Seimenis I, Papadopoulos T. Effectiveness of different adhesive primers on the bond strength between an indirect composite resin and a base metal alloy. J Prosthet Dent. 2008 May;99(5):377-87.
11. Nima G, Ferreira PVC, Paula AB, Consani S, Giannini M. Effect of Metal Primers on Bond Strength of a Composite Resin to Nickel-Chrome Metal Alloy. Braz Dent J. 2017 Jan-Apr;28(2):210-215.
12. Behr M, Rosentritt M, Gröger G, Handel G. Adhesive bond of veneering composites on various metal surfaces using silicoating, titanium-coating or functional monomers. J Dent. 2003 Jan;31(1):33-42.
13. Thalacker C. Dental adhesion with resin composites: a review and clinical tips for best practice. Br Dent J. 2022 May;232(9):615-619.
14. Yang L, Chen B, Meng H, Zhang H, He F, Xie H, et al. Bond durability when applying phosphate ester monomer-containing primers vs. self-adhesive resin cements to zirconia: Evaluation after different aging conditions. J Prosthodont Res. 2020 Apr;64(2):193-201.
15. An HS, Park JM, Park EJ. Evaluation of shear bond strengths of gingiva-colored composite resin to porcelain, metal and zirconia substrates. J Advanced Prosthodont. 2011 Sep 1;3(3):166-71.
16. Almilhatti HJ, Giampaolo ET, Vergani CE, Machado AL, Pavarina AC. Shear bond strength of aesthetic materials bonded to Ni-Cr alloy. J Dent. 2003 Mar;31(3):205-11.
17. Kim JY, Pfeiffer P, Niedermeier W. Effect of laboratory procedures and thermocycling on the shear bond strength of resin-metal bonding systems. J Prosthet Dent. 2003 Aug;90(2):184-9.
18. Amaral R, Ozcan M, Valandro LF, Balducci I, Bottino MA. Effect of conditioning methods on the microtensile bond strength of phosphate monomer-based cement on zirconia ceramic in dry and aged conditions. J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater. 2008 Apr;85(1):1-9.
19. Sheik SM, Mensudar R, Sukumaran VG, Prakash V, Karthick A, Subbiya A.Shear Bond Strength Evaluation of Composite Resin Bonded to Nickel Chromium Alloy.J Clin of Diagn Res.2018; 12(8):ZC01-ZC04.
20. Mensudar R, Sukumaran Vg, Prakash V, Karthick A, Subbiya A. Shear Bond Strength Evaluation of Composite Resin Bonded to Nickel Chromium Alloy. J Clinical & Diagnostic Research. 2018 Aug 1;12(8).
21. Ciftçi Y, Canay S, Hersek N. Shear bond strength evaluation of different veneering systems on Ni-Cr alloys. J Prosthodont. 2007 Jan-Feb;16(1):31-6.
22. Gomathi G, Nasser K.S.G.A, Janaki K, Ramkumar k, Subramaniam E. Evaluation of Shear Bond Strength of Composite Resin Veneers and Nickel-Chromium Alloy - An Invitro Study. IOSR JDMS. 2018;17(2):17-25.
23. Zhao L, Jian YT, Wang XD, Zhao K. Bond strength of primer/cement systems to zirconia subjected to artificial aging. J Prosthet Dent. 2016 Nov;116(5):790-796.
24. Kiomarsi N, Saburian P, Chiniforush N, Karazifard MJ, Hashemikamangar SS. Effect of thermocycling and surface treatment on repair bond strength of composite. J Clin Exp Dent. 2017 Aug 1;9(8):e945-e951.
25. Seabra B, Arantes-Oliveira S, Portugal J. Influence of multimode universal adhesives and zirconia primer application techniques on zirconia repair. J Prosthet Dent. 2014 Aug;112(2):182-7.
26. Qeblawi DM, Campillo-Funollet M, Muñoz CA. In vitro shear bond strength of two self-adhesive resin cements to zirconia. J Prosthet Dent. 2015 Feb;113(2):122-7.
27. Arami S, Hasani Tabatabaei M, Namdar F, Safavi N, Chiniforush N. Shear bond strength of the repair composite resin to zirconia ceramic by different surface treatment. J Lasers Med Sci. 2014 Fall;5(4):171-5.
28. Ozel GS, Inan O. Comparison of the shear bond strength of three different composite materials to metal and ceramic surfaces. Int J Composite Materials. 2016;6(4):121-8.
29. Mahgoli H, Arshad M, Rasouli K, Sobati AA, Shamshiri AR. Repair Bond Strength of Composite to Zirconia Ceramic Using Two Types of Zirconia Primers. Front Dent. 2019 Sep-Oct;16(5):342-350.
30. Zakavi F, Mombeini M, Dibazar S, Gholizadeh S. Evaluation of shear bond strength of zirconia to composite resin using different adhesive systems. J Clin Exp Dent. 2019 Mar 1;11(3):e257-e263.
31. Scaminaci Russo D, Cinelli F, Sarti C, Giachetti L. Adhesion to Zirconia: A Systematic Review of Current Conditioning Methods and Bonding Materials. Dent J (Basel). 2019 Aug 1;7(3):74.
32. de Mello CC, Bitencourt SB, Dos Santos DM, Pesqueira AA, Pellizzer EP, Goiato MC. The Effect of Surface Treatment on Shear Bond Strength between Y-TZP and Veneer Ceramic: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Prosthodont. 2018 Aug;27(7):624-635.
33. Komine F, Koizuka M, Fushiki R, Taguchi K, Kamio S, Matsumura H. Post-thermocycling shear bond strength of a gingiva-colored indirect composite layering material to three implant framework materials. Acta Odontol Scand. 2013 Sep;71(5):1092-100.
34. Ozcan M, Barbosa SH, Melo RM, Galhano GA, Bottino MA. Effect of surface conditioning methods on the microtensile bond strength of resin composite to composite after aging conditions. Dent Mater. 2007 Oct;23(10):1276-82.
2. Moses A, Ganesan L, Shankar S, Hariharan A. A comparative evaluation of shear bond strength between feldspathic porcelain and lithium di silicate ceramic layered to a zirconia core- An in vitro study. J Clin Exp Dent. 2020 Nov 1;12(11):e1039-e1044.
3. Sari F, Secilmis A, Simsek I, Ozsevik S. Shear bond strength of indirect composite material to monolithic zirconia. J Adv Prosthodont. 2016 Aug;8(4):267-74.
4. dos Santos JG, Fonseca RG, Adabo GL, dos Santos Cruz CA. Shear bond strength of metal-ceramic repair systems. J Prosthet Dent. 2006 Sep;96(3):165-73.
5. Singh A, Ramachandra K, Devarhubli AR. Evaluation and comparison of shear bond strength of porcelain to a beryllium-free alloy of nickel-chromium, nickel and beryllium free alloy of cobalt-chromium, and titanium: An in vitro study. J Indian Prosthodont Soc. 2017 Jul-Sep;17(3):261-266.
6. Yesil ZD, Karaoglanoglu S, Akyil MS, Seven N. Evaluation of the bond strength of different composite resins to porcelain and metal alloy. Int J Adhesion Adhesives. 2007 Apr 1;27(3):258-62.
7. Knight JS, Sneed WD, Wilson MC. Strengths of composite bonded to base metal alloy using dentin bonding systems. J Prosthet Dent. 2000 Aug;84(2):149-53.
8. Elsaka SE. Repair bond strength of resin composite to a novel CAD/CAM hybrid ceramic using different repair systems. Dent Mater J. 2015;34(2):161-7.
9. Choi BK, Han JS, Yang JH, Lee JB, Kim SH. Shear bond strength of veneering porcelain to zirconia and metal cores. J Adv Prosthodont. 2009 Nov;1(3):129-35.
10. Sarafianou A, Seimenis I, Papadopoulos T. Effectiveness of different adhesive primers on the bond strength between an indirect composite resin and a base metal alloy. J Prosthet Dent. 2008 May;99(5):377-87.
11. Nima G, Ferreira PVC, Paula AB, Consani S, Giannini M. Effect of Metal Primers on Bond Strength of a Composite Resin to Nickel-Chrome Metal Alloy. Braz Dent J. 2017 Jan-Apr;28(2):210-215.
12. Behr M, Rosentritt M, Gröger G, Handel G. Adhesive bond of veneering composites on various metal surfaces using silicoating, titanium-coating or functional monomers. J Dent. 2003 Jan;31(1):33-42.
13. Thalacker C. Dental adhesion with resin composites: a review and clinical tips for best practice. Br Dent J. 2022 May;232(9):615-619.
14. Yang L, Chen B, Meng H, Zhang H, He F, Xie H, et al. Bond durability when applying phosphate ester monomer-containing primers vs. self-adhesive resin cements to zirconia: Evaluation after different aging conditions. J Prosthodont Res. 2020 Apr;64(2):193-201.
15. An HS, Park JM, Park EJ. Evaluation of shear bond strengths of gingiva-colored composite resin to porcelain, metal and zirconia substrates. J Advanced Prosthodont. 2011 Sep 1;3(3):166-71.
16. Almilhatti HJ, Giampaolo ET, Vergani CE, Machado AL, Pavarina AC. Shear bond strength of aesthetic materials bonded to Ni-Cr alloy. J Dent. 2003 Mar;31(3):205-11.
17. Kim JY, Pfeiffer P, Niedermeier W. Effect of laboratory procedures and thermocycling on the shear bond strength of resin-metal bonding systems. J Prosthet Dent. 2003 Aug;90(2):184-9.
18. Amaral R, Ozcan M, Valandro LF, Balducci I, Bottino MA. Effect of conditioning methods on the microtensile bond strength of phosphate monomer-based cement on zirconia ceramic in dry and aged conditions. J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater. 2008 Apr;85(1):1-9.
19. Sheik SM, Mensudar R, Sukumaran VG, Prakash V, Karthick A, Subbiya A.Shear Bond Strength Evaluation of Composite Resin Bonded to Nickel Chromium Alloy.J Clin of Diagn Res.2018; 12(8):ZC01-ZC04.
20. Mensudar R, Sukumaran Vg, Prakash V, Karthick A, Subbiya A. Shear Bond Strength Evaluation of Composite Resin Bonded to Nickel Chromium Alloy. J Clinical & Diagnostic Research. 2018 Aug 1;12(8).
21. Ciftçi Y, Canay S, Hersek N. Shear bond strength evaluation of different veneering systems on Ni-Cr alloys. J Prosthodont. 2007 Jan-Feb;16(1):31-6.
22. Gomathi G, Nasser K.S.G.A, Janaki K, Ramkumar k, Subramaniam E. Evaluation of Shear Bond Strength of Composite Resin Veneers and Nickel-Chromium Alloy - An Invitro Study. IOSR JDMS. 2018;17(2):17-25.
23. Zhao L, Jian YT, Wang XD, Zhao K. Bond strength of primer/cement systems to zirconia subjected to artificial aging. J Prosthet Dent. 2016 Nov;116(5):790-796.
24. Kiomarsi N, Saburian P, Chiniforush N, Karazifard MJ, Hashemikamangar SS. Effect of thermocycling and surface treatment on repair bond strength of composite. J Clin Exp Dent. 2017 Aug 1;9(8):e945-e951.
25. Seabra B, Arantes-Oliveira S, Portugal J. Influence of multimode universal adhesives and zirconia primer application techniques on zirconia repair. J Prosthet Dent. 2014 Aug;112(2):182-7.
26. Qeblawi DM, Campillo-Funollet M, Muñoz CA. In vitro shear bond strength of two self-adhesive resin cements to zirconia. J Prosthet Dent. 2015 Feb;113(2):122-7.
27. Arami S, Hasani Tabatabaei M, Namdar F, Safavi N, Chiniforush N. Shear bond strength of the repair composite resin to zirconia ceramic by different surface treatment. J Lasers Med Sci. 2014 Fall;5(4):171-5.
28. Ozel GS, Inan O. Comparison of the shear bond strength of three different composite materials to metal and ceramic surfaces. Int J Composite Materials. 2016;6(4):121-8.
29. Mahgoli H, Arshad M, Rasouli K, Sobati AA, Shamshiri AR. Repair Bond Strength of Composite to Zirconia Ceramic Using Two Types of Zirconia Primers. Front Dent. 2019 Sep-Oct;16(5):342-350.
30. Zakavi F, Mombeini M, Dibazar S, Gholizadeh S. Evaluation of shear bond strength of zirconia to composite resin using different adhesive systems. J Clin Exp Dent. 2019 Mar 1;11(3):e257-e263.
31. Scaminaci Russo D, Cinelli F, Sarti C, Giachetti L. Adhesion to Zirconia: A Systematic Review of Current Conditioning Methods and Bonding Materials. Dent J (Basel). 2019 Aug 1;7(3):74.
32. de Mello CC, Bitencourt SB, Dos Santos DM, Pesqueira AA, Pellizzer EP, Goiato MC. The Effect of Surface Treatment on Shear Bond Strength between Y-TZP and Veneer Ceramic: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Prosthodont. 2018 Aug;27(7):624-635.
33. Komine F, Koizuka M, Fushiki R, Taguchi K, Kamio S, Matsumura H. Post-thermocycling shear bond strength of a gingiva-colored indirect composite layering material to three implant framework materials. Acta Odontol Scand. 2013 Sep;71(5):1092-100.
34. Ozcan M, Barbosa SH, Melo RM, Galhano GA, Bottino MA. Effect of surface conditioning methods on the microtensile bond strength of resin composite to composite after aging conditions. Dent Mater. 2007 Oct;23(10):1276-82.
| Issue | Vol 20 (Continuously Published Article-Based) | |
| Section | Original Article | |
| DOI | https://doi.org/10.18502/fid.v20i43.14381 | |
| Keywords | ||
| Metal Ceramic Alloys Shear Strength Zirconia Composite Resins | ||
| Rights and permissions | |
|
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. |
How to Cite
1.
Arshad M, Gordan R, Farrokhi P, Habibzadeh S. Composite Resin Bond Strength to Zirconia and Base Metal Alloys Using Two Types of Intraoral Porcelain Repair Systems. Front Dent. 2023;20.
